— THE SOURCES ON THE STARS —

Jewish astrology — what Judaism, the Talmud and Kabbalah actually say

מַזָּל · מַזָּלוֹת

Judaism has no single position on astrology. The Talmud records a real dispute: Rabbi Chanina held that the stars shape a person, including a Jew, and Rabbi Yochanan held that "there is no mazal for Israel" (Shabbat 156a). Later authorities split along similar lines. Maimonides called astrology falsehood. Abraham ibn Ezra wrote a whole shelf of astrological textbooks. Jewish law, as codified in the Shulchan Aruch, forbids consulting astrologers. What all of them share is a refusal to let a star chart replace a person's relationship with God or their responsibility for what they do.

This guide sets out what the classical sources say, quoted and cited, and then explains where JewishZodiac.com's own interpretation begins.

What "Jewish astrology" means

"Jewish astrology" is used for at least four different things, and most confusion comes from mixing them up:

  1. The Hebrew names of the zodiac. Hebrew has its own names for the twelve constellations, and Jewish texts pair them with the twelve Hebrew months. This is a naming and calendar tradition. It is not, by itself, a method of prediction.
  2. Talmudic statements about mazal. The Babylonian Talmud discusses whether the day and hour of birth shape character, and whether prayer and good deeds can change what the stars indicate (Shabbat 156a–b; Moed Katan 28a).
  3. Medieval Jewish astrology as a technical science. Some medieval Jewish scholars, above all Abraham ibn Ezra, wrote astrological treatises on nativities, elections and interrogations, in the tradition of Arabic astrology.
  4. Kabbalistic correspondences. Sefer Yetzirah links letters of the Hebrew alphabet with constellations, months and parts of the body. Later writers added the twelve tribes and built a spiritual reading of each month on top of it.

None of these is the modern newspaper horoscope, and none of them is a single "Jewish system." Each needs to be read on its own terms.

Mazal and mazalot

The Hebrew word mazal (מזל) originally means a constellation or sign of the zodiac. In the Hebrew Bible it appears exactly once, in the plural mazalot, at 2 Kings 23:5. There King Josiah suppresses the priests "who made offerings to Baal, to the sun and moon and constellations [ve-la-mazalot] — all the host of heaven." Klein's etymological dictionary traces the word to Akkadian mazzaztu / mazaltu, "the standing of the stars." It lists the later sense "luck, fortune" as post-biblical Hebrew.

The related verse people often cite, Deuteronomy 4:19, warns against bowing to "the sun and the moon and the stars, the whole heavenly host." The Hebrew says kokhavim (stars), not mazalot. Job 38:32 uses a similar word, mazzarot, which the JPS translation leaves untranslated with the note "evidently a constellation." More on these verses is in the zodiac in the Bible.

The Mishnah uses mazalot in the same sense. In Avodah Zarah 4:7, idolaters "worship the sun and the moon and the stars and the constellations [ve-la-mazalot]." In the Talmud, mazal comes to mean both the constellation and what it was thought to confer on a person. That is the sense in Shabbat 156a: "mazal makes one wise, mazal makes one wealthy."

So mazal tov literally means "a good constellation." In everyday use it is a congratulation, and most people who say it intend no astrological claim. This page makes none either.

The twelve signs in Jewish tradition

Sefer Yetzirah gives the twelve constellations their Hebrew names and lists them in the same order as the twelve months, beginning with Nisan.

Hebrew monthHebrew signMeaning of the Hebrew nameWestern equivalent
NisanTaleh (טלה)lamb / ramAries
IyarShor (שור)ox / bullTaurus
SivanTeomim (תאומים)twinsGemini
TammuzSartan (סרטן)crabCancer
AvAryeh (אריה)lionLeo
ElulBetulah (בתולה)virginVirgo
TishreiMoznayim (מאזנים)scalesLibra
CheshvanAkrav (עקרב)scorpionScorpio
KislevKeshet (קשת)bowSagittarius
TevetGedi (גדי)kid / young goatCapricorn
ShevatDli (דלי)bucketAquarius
AdarDagim (דגים)fishPisces

The same twelve Hebrew names appear as labels in ancient synagogue mosaics, and as a written list in the Ein Gedi synagogue inscription (see below). For a sign-by-sign guide, see the twelve Jewish zodiac signs. To find your Hebrew birth month, use the Hebrew birthday calculator.

One practical difference from Western astrology: a Hebrew month is lunar. Its days do not match fixed Gregorian date ranges, and in a leap year the calendar adds a second Adar. Sefer Yetzirah lists only twelve months. How a reading handles Adar I and Adar II is a choice the interpreter makes, not something the text decides. The Jewish calendar shows the month boundaries for each year.

Sefer Yetzirah, chapter 5: what it says and what it does not

Sefer Yetzirah ("The Book of Formation") is a short, early cosmological text. Its date is debated. Chapter 5 deals with the twelve "simple" letters: ה ו ז ח ט י ל נ ס ע צ ק (Heh, Vav, Zayin, Chet, Tet, Yod, Lamed, Nun, Samekh, Ayin, Tzadi, Kuf).

What it does assign. In the version associated with the Vilna Gaon (the "Gra version," translated by Aryeh Kaplan on Sefaria), each letter is "made king" over a human faculty. With it God forms a constellation "in the universe," a month "in the year," and an organ "in the soul." For Nisan the text reads: "He made the letter Heh king over speech… and formed with them Aries in the Universe, Nissan in the Year, and the right foot in the Soul" (Sefer Yetzirah, Gra version 5:7). The twelve faculties in that version are speech, thought, motion, sight, hearing, action, coition, smell, sleep, anger, taste (literally "swallowing," le'itah) and laughter (5:1).

The versions disagree. Sefer Yetzirah survives in several recensions, and they are not interchangeable. The text Sefaria presents as its default "Sefer Yetzirah" (Warsaw 1884) lists the faculties in a different order, starting with sight, hearing and smell. Its letter-by-letter section pairs each letter with a constellation, a month and an organ, but not with a faculty. Its organs also differ: Nisan gets the right hand, where the Gra version has the right foot (Sefer Yetzirah 5:1–2). Any page that cites "Sefer Yetzirah 5" for a specific faculty or organ should say which version it means.

What it does not assign: the tribes. Sefer Yetzirah chapter 5 does not mention the twelve tribes of Israel in any version checked for this article. The tribe connections come from later commentators, and they do not all agree:

The month–tribe pairing JewishZodiac.com uses (Nisan–Judah through Adar–Naftali) follows this banner order. For nine months it agrees with the Ra'avad commentary's faculty–tribe pairing. For Elul, Tishrei and Cheshvan it does not: the Ra'avad commentary gives coition to Levi and smell to Yosef, where the banner order gives Tishrei to Ephraim and Cheshvan to Menashe, and it names no tribe for action. The tribe for each month is therefore later tradition, and more than one tradition exists.

Shabbat 156a–b: "Ein mazal le-Yisrael"

The main Talmudic discussion is at the end of tractate Shabbat. It is presented as a dispute, and it should be read as one.

The setting. Rabbi Yehoshua ben Levi's notebook lists what a person born on each day of the week will be like. Rabbi Chanina replies: "It is not the mazal of the day that determines, but the mazal of the hour." He goes on to describe a person born under the sun, Venus, Mercury, the moon, Saturn, Jupiter and Mars (Shabbat 156a).

The dispute. "Rabbi Chanina says: Mazal makes one wise, mazal makes one wealthy, and there is mazal for Israel (yesh mazal le-Yisrael). Rabbi Yochanan said: There is no mazal for Israel (ein mazal le-Yisrael)." Rabbi Yochanan cites Jeremiah 10:2: "Learn not the way of the nations, and be not dismayed at the signs of heaven; for the nations are dismayed at them." The nations will be dismayed, the Talmud says, but not Israel (Shabbat 156a; the William Davidson translation renders mazal here as "constellation").

Abraham. Rav also holds there is no mazal for Israel. He reads Genesis 15:5, "And He brought him outside," as God's answer to Abraham's complaint: "I looked at my astrological map (itztagninut), and I am not fit to have a son." God replies: "Go out from your astrology, for there is no mazal for Israel" (Shabbat 156a–b).

The stories. The Talmud then brings three stories as proof of Rabbi Yochanan's view (Shabbat 156b):

How the commentators read it. Even the commentators who explain the passage do not erase the dispute. Rashi explains Rabbi Chanina's "there is mazal for Israel" to mean "prayer and charity do not change the mazal." He explains Rabbi Yochanan's "there is no mazal for Israel" to mean "through prayer and merit one's mazal changes for the good" (Rashi on Shabbat 156a, s.v. mazal machkim and ein mazal le-Yisrael; our translation). On this reading, Rabbi Yochanan's position is not that the stars mean nothing. It is that their indication can be changed. A closer reading of the passage is in our essay Ein mazal l'Yisrael.

Moed Katan 28a: "not on merit but on mazal"

A second passage pulls the other way. "Rava said: Length of life, children, and sustenance do not depend on one's merit, but rather they depend upon mazal." His proof: Rabba and Rav Chisda were both righteous, and both could pray for rain and see it fall. Yet Rav Chisda lived to ninety-two and Rabba to forty. One house had sixty weddings, the other "sixty calamities." In Rav Chisda's house even the dogs ate fine bread, while in Rabba's there was not enough coarse barley bread for the people (Moed Katan 28a). The William Davidson translation renders mazala here as "fate."

Tosafot raise the contradiction with Shabbat 156a directly. Their answer: "sometimes it changes through great merit, but sometimes the mazal does not change" (Tosafot on Shabbat 156a, s.v. ein mazal le-Yisrael; also Tosafot on Moed Katan 28a; our translation). That is a harmonisation offered by later commentators, not a statement of the Talmud itself.

Maimonides' opposition

Maimonides (Rambam) is the strongest classical opponent of astrology.

In law. The Mishneh Torah defines a me'onen, a forbidden practitioner of times, as one who says "through astrology" (be-itztagninut) that a given day, month or year is good or bad for something (Hilkhot Avodat Kokhavim 11:8). It rules that "anyone who performs a deed because of an astrological calculation or arranges his work or his journeys to fit a time that was suggested by the astrologers is [liable for] lashes," citing Leviticus 19:26 (11:9, Touger translation). At the end of the chapter he calls all these practices "falsehood and lies." Whoever believes they are true "and words of wisdom, but are forbidden by the Torah, is foolish and feebleminded." The Torah's answer, he writes, is Deuteronomy 18:13: "Be of perfect faith with God, your Lord" (11:16, Touger translation).

In the Guide. In the Guide of the Perplexed III:37, he states that "it is the object and centre of the whole Law to abolish idolatry… and to overthrow the opinion that any of the stars could interfere for good or evil in human matters" (Friedländer translation). In III:29 he describes the star worship of the "Sabeans," which he presents as the world Abraham left. In his commentary on Mishnah Avodah Zarah 4:7, he complains that "even the good and pious of our faith" think such practices are real but forbidden. In his view they are simply false.

The Letter on Astrology. A circle of scholars in southern France, led by R. Jonathan ha-Kohen (later of Lunel), wrote to Maimonides asking whether astrology was legitimate, and asked for the reply to be sent to Montpellier. His answer, usually dated 1194, is known as the Letter on Astrology. Printed editions since the sixteenth century call it a letter to the sages of Marseille, a title the historian Alexander Marx considered a mistake. Marx edited the correspondence in 1926. Shlomo Sela published a critical edition and English translation of the rabbis' questions in 2004 and showed that they draw on Abraham ibn Ezra. Ralph Lerner translated Maimonides' reply into English. In the letter, Maimonides says a person should accept only what is proven by reason, perceived by the senses, or received from the prophets. He separates astronomy, a true science, from judicial astrology, which he dismisses as folly. He treats astrology as a root of idolatry, and says that Talmudic sayings which seem to support it are the opinions of individual sages, which do not outweigh demonstrated reason. A few scholars, notably Herbert Davidson, have questioned whether the letter is authentic; most treat it as Maimonides' own.

Abraham ibn Ezra's astrological writings

Abraham ibn Ezra (born around 1093, probably in Tudela) is best known for his Torah commentary. He was also the most important astrological author in medieval Hebrew. The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy entry on him says that "the central place of astrology in Ibn Ezra's thought must be singled out." It notes that his astrological tracts usually survive in at least two versions, and that their Latin versions "played a pivotal role in the spread of that art throughout Christian Europe."

His Hebrew astrological works have been edited and translated by Shlomo Sela in the Brill series Abraham Ibn Ezra's Astrological Writings. The series includes Sefer ha-Te'amim (The Book of Reasons), Sefer ha-'Olam (The Book of the World), the books of Elections, Interrogations and the Luminaries, the books of Nativities and Revolution, and Reshit Ḥokhmah (The Beginning of Wisdom) with Mishpeṭei ha-Mazzalot (2017). According to Sela, Reshit Ḥokhmah draws on Hebrew translations or paraphrases of Abū Maʿshar and Sahl ibn Bishr.

His astrology also appears in his Torah commentary. On Deuteronomy 4:19 he writes: "It has been empirically established that each and every nation has a specific star and constellation… God raised Israel to a very high level in that God, and not any star, is Israel's guide" (Strickman–Silver translation). The SEP entry points out the tension. The commentaries seem to exempt Israel from astral decrees, while "in his astrological writings, the Jews are no different from other peoples."

Tamim tihyeh: the prohibition on consulting astrologers

The legal line runs through one verse: "You must be wholehearted (tamim tihyeh) with the LORD your God" (Deuteronomy 18:13).

Note what the codified law does and does not say. It forbids consulting astrologers and acting on their timings. It does not declare that the heavens have no effect. The Rema leaves room for avoiding what one already knows to be inauspicious, while forbidding the search for it.

Ramban's view of the heavens

Ramban is not a Maimonidean on this question. In his comment on Deuteronomy 18:9 he writes that God "made the higher powers to be guides for those below them." God placed the earth "in the power of the stars and constellations, depending on their rotation and position as proven by the study of astrology." He adds that the higher powers can reverse a good or bad configuration (Chavel translation). He also says outright that "many scholars" who deny any truth in these arts are wrong, because "we cannot deny matters publicly demonstrated." Chavel's note identifies those scholars as Rambam and his followers. For Ramban the prohibition does not rest on astrology being false. It rests on the Torah's demand that a Jew turn to God alone (18:13).

Ancient synagogue zodiac mosaics

The strongest physical evidence that Jews engaged with the zodiac is the synagogue floors of Roman and Byzantine Palestine.

What the zodiacs meant is disputed. Scholars have read them as a calendar, the signs paired with the months of the liturgical year. Others read them as a decorative convention borrowed from the surrounding culture, or as an image of cosmic order under God's rule. Lucille Roussin reports Weiss's reading of the Sepphoris wheel as a reminder of nature's cycle and of God's omnipotence. Jodi Magness argues that the central figure was meant to be read on more than one level: as Helios, the sun, and also as Metatron, the "super-angel" of Jewish mystical (hekhalot) literature; in her view it was not an image of God. She reads the whole design as sacred time and sacred space meeting in the synagogue ("Heaven on Earth: Helios and the Zodiac Cycle in Ancient Palestinian Synagogues," Dumbarton Oaks Papers 59, 2005, pp. 1–52; see pp. 7–8, 31–32, 49). Her identification is one scholarly proposal among several, not a consensus. No inscription on these floors explains the zodiac's purpose. The mosaics show the zodiac inside the synagogue. They do not show that the congregation practised horoscopic prediction.

Historical astrology vs. modern sun-sign horoscopes

The Talmud's discussion and medieval Jewish astrology are both far from the modern horoscope column.

The Hebrew-month signs do not line up neatly with Western sun-sign dates, because each Hebrew month begins with the new moon and drifts against the solar calendar from year to year. Someone who is a Western Aries may have been born in Adar or in Nisan.

Free will, providence, and competing views

The sources do not resolve into one doctrine. Here are the main positions, each limited to what was checked for this article:

What JewishZodiac.com offers

JewishZodiac.com is a modern interpretive tool. It takes a person's Hebrew birth date, calculated from the Hebrew calendar, and the classical correspondences described above (month, sign, letter, faculty, and the tribe given by later tradition). It then writes a reflective portrait from them. It does not predict events, and it does not claim that the stars determine anything. The sources above give reasons for that restraint: halakha forbids consulting astrologers (Pesachim 113b; Shulchan Aruch YD 179:1), and the Talmud's own position is disputed (Shabbat 156a).

The month-level data is fixed by rule: which Hebrew month, which sign, which letter. The tribe follows the order of the banners, as in the Bnei Yissaschar. Where a reading draws on a specific text, it names the source. The written portrait is the site's own interpretation. It is not a quotation from any of these works, and none of them endorses it. More on sources and method is on the About page. To see the method applied, you can begin a free Jewish zodiac reading from a birth date, compare two Hebrew months in the compatibility guide, or read two people's charts together in the relationship reading.

Frequently asked questions

Does Judaism believe in astrology?

There is no single Jewish position. The Talmud records a dispute: Rabbi Chanina says "there is mazal for Israel," and Rabbi Yochanan says "there is no mazal for Israel" (Shabbat 156a). Maimonides rejected astrology as false. Ramban and Ibn Ezra accepted that the heavens have influence. All of them agree that a Jew should not consult astrologers (Pesachim 113b; Shulchan Aruch YD 179:1).

Is it forbidden for Jews to read horoscopes?

Halakha forbids consulting astrologers and acting on astrological timings. The Shulchan Aruch, Yoreh De'ah 179:1, rules that "one does not inquire of those who look at the stars," and Maimonides makes acting on such timings punishable (Avodat Kokhavim 11:9). How this applies to reading a horoscope column is a question for one's rabbi. This page does not give a ruling.

What does "ein mazal le-Yisrael" mean?

Literally, "there is no mazal (constellation) for Israel." It is Rabbi Yochanan's position in Shabbat 156a, against Rabbi Chanina. Rashi explains it as meaning that prayer and merit can change a person's mazal for the good. It does not mean the stars have no meaning at all.

Does Sefer Yetzirah assign a tribe to each month?

No. Sefer Yetzirah chapter 5 assigns letters, constellations, months, faculties and organs, with differences between versions. Tribes are added by later commentators. The Ra'avad commentary pairs tribes with faculties. The Bnei Yissaschar pairs them with months by the order of the banners in Numbers 10.

Why does my Jewish zodiac sign differ from my Western sign?

The Jewish sign follows the Hebrew month you were born in, and Hebrew months follow the moon. Western sun signs follow fixed solar dates, so the two can differ. Use the Hebrew birthday calculator to find your Hebrew month.

Were there really zodiacs in ancient synagogues?

Yes. Zodiac mosaics with Hebrew labels survive at Hammat Tiberias, Beit Alpha, Sepphoris and Na'aran, and the Ein Gedi synagogue has the signs and months written out as an inscription. Their purpose is debated by scholars.

Sources

Every text below was checked against the linked edition while this guide was written.

  1. Klein Dictionary, מַזָּל — sefaria.org
  2. II Kings 23:5 — sefaria.org
  3. Deuteronomy 4:19 — sefaria.org
  4. Job 38:32 — sefaria.org
  5. Mishnah Avodah Zarah 4:7 — sefaria.org
  6. Sefer Yetzirah Gra Version 5:1, 5:3-5:10 (Nisan at 5:7) — sefaria.org
  7. Sefer Yetzirah 5:1-5:2 — sefaria.org
  8. Ra'avad on Sefer Yetzirah 5:1, segment 2 (segment 1 lists faculties and says they flow to the 12 tribes) — sefaria.org
  9. Bnei Yissaschar, Tishrei 1:1 (Ma'amar 1) — sefaria.org
  10. Numbers 10:14-27 — sefaria.org
  11. Shabbat 156a (Sefaria segment 11) — sefaria.org
  12. Shabbat 156a (Sefaria segment 12) — sefaria.org
  13. Shabbat 156a-b (156a segments 13-14; 156b segment 1) — sefaria.org
  14. Shabbat 156b (Sefaria segments 2-7) — sefaria.org
  15. Rashi on Shabbat 156a:12:1 (s.v. mazal machkim) and 156a:12:2 (s.v. ein mazal le-Yisrael) — sefaria.org
  16. Moed Katan 28a (Sefaria segments 13-15) — sefaria.org
  17. Tosafot on Shabbat 156a:12:1 (s.v. ein mazal le-Yisrael); cf. Tosafot on Moed Katan 28a:13:1 — sefaria.org
  18. Hilkhot Avodat Kokhavim (Foreign Worship) 11:8 — sefaria.org
  19. Hilkhot Avodat Kokhavim 11:9 — sefaria.org
  20. Hilkhot Avodat Kokhavim 11:16 — sefaria.org
  21. Part 3, ch. 37 — sefaria.org
  22. Part 3, ch. 29 — sefaria.org
  23. Rambam on Mishnah Avodah Zarah 4:7 — sefaria.org
  24. Posen Library node 12885 — posenlibrary.com
  25. HUCA 3 (1926); Aleph 4 (2004); Lerner 2000 — tpsalomonreinach.mom.fr
  26. Section 1 — plato.stanford.edu
  27. Sections 1-2 — plato.stanford.edu
  28. Sela 2007, 2010, 2011, 2013, 2017 — paris-iea.fr
  29. Ibn Ezra on Deuteronomy 4:19:3 — sefaria.org
  30. Deuteronomy 18:13 — sefaria.org
  31. Pesachim 113b (Sefaria segment 15) — sefaria.org
  32. Rashi on Deuteronomy 18:13:1 — sefaria.org
  33. Ramban on Deuteronomy 18:13:1 — sefaria.org
  34. Yoreh De'ah 179:1 — sefaria.org
  35. Yoreh De'ah 179:2 — sefaria.org
  36. Ramban on Deuteronomy 18:9:1 — sefaria.org
  37. Wars of the Lord II.2 pp. 33-35; I.12 p. 219 (as quoted in SEP) — plato.stanford.edu
  38. IIP tibe0001 — search.inscriptionsisraelpalestine.org
  39. Archaeology in Israel: Beit Alpha — jewishvirtuallibrary.org
  40. n/a — en.wikipedia.org
  41. COJS page — cojs.org
  42. BAR 27:2 (March/April 2001) — en.wikipedia.org
  43. pp. 1-52 — archive.org
— CONTINUE —
The twelve mazalot

Every sign with its Hebrew name, month, letter and faculty.

Find your Hebrew birthday

The calculator converts your birth date and names your month's mazal.

Ein mazal l'Yisrael

The Shabbat 156a dispute, read closely.

Written by the Jewish Zodiac editorial desk. Sources checked against the editions linked above (Sefaria for rabbinic texts). Method note: the last section separates the historical sources from this site's own interpretation. Corrections welcome at support@jewishzodiac.com. Published 12 November 2026.
The Daily Tikkun
Your sign, every morning.

The Daily Tikkun turns your Hebrew month into a daily practice — a real verse from the day, a personal mirror, one small ask. Included with membership.

Read today’s Tikkun →
Today’s read is free to see · the morning email comes with membership